2012

La Costanera Restaurant Review, Montara

Posted by Foodnut.com

Reviewer: Foodnut.com

La Costanera

8150 Cabrillo Hwy

Montara, CA 94037

650-728-1600

650-728-1601 (Fax)

La Costanera Website

Book Reservation

La Costanera Montara exterior decor

Why did we dine here? – La Costanera received One Michelin Star for 2012, raising the restaurant’s profile and putting it on our hit list. They focus on Peruvian cuisine and are located above the beach in Montara in a nice multi level building that housed The Chart House.

La Costanera has fire pits outside as well as a lounge downstairs.

La Costanera Montara Interior decor

Insider Tip – Come when the sun is still up, otherwise the sea is pitch black. Visit the beach before hand.

Cuisine – Peruvian
Location – Montara, 10 minutes north of Half Moon Bay
Opened – 2010

Service – La Costanera had very good service with a pretty informed waiter. Clearly they are trying hard.
Verdict – La Costanera could have easily served up marginal food in a venue with a killer view, but instead validated the Michelin star with some solid Peruvian food.
On a budget, enjoy the view and come for a drink and an appetizer during happy hour.

Signature Dishes – Cebiche, Tiradito, Empanadas.

La Costanera’s Menu has a wide variety of its from Peruvian ones to Mac and Cheese to Gnocchi! Stick to the Peruvian dishes

Website La Costanera Menu

La Costanera Picks:
Sangria ($8) with passion fruit was a special and tasted fruit and well balanced.

La Costanera Montara sangria cocktails pisco punch

Pisco Punch ($10) PISCO PORTON, Pineapple juice, simple syrup, lemon was strong, not fruity, and pretty potent.

Chicha Morada ($5) a non alcoholic Peruvian purple-corn drink that is sweet, spicy, and fruity. Fun for the designated driver.

La Costanera Montara Tiradito de Concha scallop

Tiradito de Concha “Raw” ($17) Pan seared fresh sea scallops thinly sliced with aji Amaraillo, tiradito sauce, avocado & crispy nori was very good with large scallops atop some zesty sauces.

La Costanera Montara sirloin steak Anticucho de Res

Anticucho de Res ($14) Sirloin steak with crispy potato & chimichurri on a skewer was very well done with a large portion of tender steak.

La Costanera Montara Beef Tenderloin Lomo Saltado

Lomo Saltado ($23) Stir fried beef tenderloin, with onions, tomatoes, fries & soy sauce, rice was excellent. Lots of tender, juicy meat cooked to a perfect medium rare. Fries sopped up all the meaty juices. We last had this at Limon in SF.

La Costanera Montara grilled octopus Pulpito a la Parilla

Pulpito a la Parilla ($13) Grilled baby octopus marinated in aderezo peruano with papa seco (carapulcra) contanted several skewers lined with crusty octopus cooked just right.

La Costanera Montara Fish Pescado a lo Macho

Pescado a lo Macho ($28) Seasonal fish fillet (Walu) topped with a spicy seafood stew in a mild rocolo pimento sauce contained a large chunk of well cooked fish topped off with mussels and chewy calamari.

Platano fritto ($6) had tender plantins dusted with powered sugar and a caramel dip.

Sautee Spinach ($6) was plain, oily, and pretty clean cut.

La Costanera Montara Brioch Bread Pudding

Brioch Bread Pudding ($8) Brioche-Quinoa Bread pudding with lucuma ice cream (Weekends only) was huge and pretty meaty. Some nice tropical ice cream accompanied this dessert.

La Costanera OK: (Order if you like this dish)
None

Pans: (We would not reorder these dishes)
None

La Costanera on Urbanspoon

La Costanera Overall Rating: (Very Good 2.5)

Come Back?

Food Rating: (Very Good)
Service Rating: (Very Good)
Atmosphere Rating: (Very Good)
Value Rating: (Good)

Guide: 0 = poor, 1 = Below/Average, 2 = Good, 2.5 = Very Good, 3 = Excellent , 4 = Extraordinary

Alcohol:Full Bar
Attire:Dressy
Hours:Tue-Thu, Sun 5 pm - 9:30 pm, Fri-Sat 5 pm - 10:30 pm, Closed Monday
Parking:Free Lot
Reservations:Yes
Posted on January 25th, 2012
If you enjoyed this post, like us on Facebook and Follow us on Twitter.
Be sure to subscribe to our RSS feed.

3 Responses to “La Costanera Restaurant Review, Montara”

  1. New Michelin Guide San Francisco 2012 | Foodnut.com Says:

    […] Hmm – Bib Gourmand with us Frances – San Francisco Gary Danko – San Francisco La Costanera – Half Moon Bay – Shocking! La Folie – San Francisco La Toque – Napa Luce – […]

  2. Michael Bauer's 2012 Top 100 Bay Area Restaurants | Foodnut.com Says:

    […] La Costanera – Peruvian needs representation! […]

  3. New Michelin Guide San Francisco 2013 | Foodnut.com Says:

    […] & Restaurant – Forestville Frances – San Francisco Gary Danko – San Francisco La Costanera – Half Moon Bay – Not that great! La Folie – San Francisco La Toque – Napa […]

Leave a Reply

Please do not put your URL in the comment text and please use your PERSONAL name or initials and not your business name.