2013

Kingfish Restaurant Review, San Mateo

Posted by Foodnut.com

Reviewer: Foodnut.com

Kingfish

201 South B Street (@2nd ave)

San Mateo, CA 94401

650-343-1226

Kingfish Website

Book Reservation

Kingfish San Mateo exterior decor

Kingfish is a fun New Orleans/Southern focused restaurant in San Mateo. They had a location in San Francisco but that closed.. The place is prime draw for this sleepy suburb as it is around the corner from the Cinemark Theaters and is one of the few places that stays open late. They focus on using organic, antibiotic & steroid-free meats. Our last visit was in March 2014.

The Foster City Costco sells discounted gift cards for this restaurant. A Pacfic Catch opened a couple doors down, probably impacting their business.

Kingfish San Mateo Interior decor

Decor, Vibe – Kingfish’s walls are filled with wild and colorful Southern Folk Art adding to a fun vibe. Couples, families, a more upscale crowd than most restaurants in downtown San Mateo. They have two floors with an additional bar area upstairs.

Kingfish Menu pics

Kingfish’s menu features a wide variety of items, some Cajun, others simply American. They have specials each day.

Kingfish Website Menu

Kingfish Picks:

Mojito Cubanito ($9.50) – A nice balanced mojito drink with coconut accented liquor. This place clearly knows how to pour cocktails.

Kingfish San Mateo Cocktails

Pomegranate Drop ($11) Anti-Oxidant rich!…And Vodka rich too!! Belvedere vodka, pomegranate juice, hint of apple. Not as foo foo as you would think. Pretty strong and good for you!

Boomerang Cosmo ($9) Ultra cool Boomerang Vodka from Australia, Combier, cranberry juice, fresh squeezed lime, served up was good and strong.

Weed Wacker ($9) Jeremiah’s Weed sweet tea vodka, fresh lemonade, topped with Ginger ale, shaken and served up. Recommended by our server, this cocktail is on the sweet side but was balanced and is highly recommended.

Hurricane ($12) is tall and strong.  If you want to get zonked fast, go for it.

Butter lettuce salad ($10) green apples, cane syrup candied pecans, goat cheese,
apple-vanilla seed vinaigrette was pretty good and no that sweet.

Chopped salad  ($9) chopped cabbage, romaine and radicchio, toasted
peanuts, crispy won ton strips, honey-mustard with grilled organic chicken ($7) was pretty large and full of diced chicken. A nice crunchy salad with a lite dressing.

Clam chowder  ($9) fresh littleneck clams, smoked bacon, Yukon potatoes was huge. Full of clams and cream.

Cheese and Garlic Bread ($6) was hot and slathered in cheese. Lots of garlic flavor.

Steamed Mussels and Clams ($13) was quickly cooked on an induction plate in front of us.  Lots of mussels and clams that tasted great.  The sauce was really good, so load up on bread and dip your heart away.  Consider ordering some rice to sop up this good stuff.

Scallop Appetizer ($13.95) came with two of the biggest scallops we’d ever had.  Cooked pretty well with a nice carmelized coating.  They sat on top of a black bean/ Yukon potato cakes.  A pretty good dish. The was removed from the menu in 2014.

Kingfish San Mateo Tuna Tartare

Tuna tartare ($15) number 1 tuna, sesame, shoyu, ginger, scallion, fresh mango puree, taro chips. This dish was recommended by the server and proved to be an excellent recommendation. Fresh tuna, cubed and intermixed with some nice Asian flavors.

Ahi Tuna Salad ($22) was added to the menu in the middle of 2013 and consists of a salad with liberal slices of ahi on top.  Not as good as the Tuna tartare, but still worth ordering.

Ice cold oysters ($25 for a dozen) included very fresh shigoku, skookum, pearl point, miyagi the Shallot dipping sauce was very tart. We just stuck to the lemons.

Kingfish San Mateo Lobster

Friday’s Special lobster boil with fixin’s  ($35) Maine Lobster, brentwood corn, Silva Sausage Co. Spicy Sausage, was an excellent combination. Freshly steamed lobster, definitely hit the spot. We saw several other tables with same dish. This special  was removed on our last visit.

Kingfish San Mateo Prime Rib

Slow roasted prime rib | au jus – certified black angus | nebraska ($32) was a pretty large slice of medium rare tender meat along with some asparagus and a large baked potato. This will surely satisfy any meat fan.

Scallops + Etouffée ($29) hand harvested jumbo U-8 scallops, crawfish, shrimp, mahogany roux,served traditionally ‘smothered’ over long grain rice Atlantic was recommended by our server and frankly was a spicy dish very similar to the Jambalaya.

Fish and Chips ($17) had 3 pieces of freshly fried fish, which were a bit on the small side. Quality was fine, and the fries were thin and good.

Wagyu ribeye ($48 for 12 oz) black peppered and grilled, vidalia onion-potato gratin  creamed fresh baby spinach, smoked shallot butter, red wine sauce snake river is extremely expensive but worthwhile. Tender, charcoaly, and cooked just right. The potatoes were pretty rich.

Jambalaya ($24) famous shrimp, chicken, andouille, mussels, sweet peppers, long grain rice,  braised in a spicy shrimp stock is a classic dish and proved to be a decent one too. High on quantity, HIGH on the heat, 3 large shrimp, and lots of chopped sausage.

Kingfish San Mateo Skirt Steak

Skirt steak  + rings  ($25) certified Angus beef  from Oregon with garlic mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus and onion rings was a popular dish that featured a tender and correctly cooked slice of beef.

Kingfish San Mateo Beignets

New orleans beignets ($8) cafe du monde chicory coffee | valrhôna bittersweet chocolate – the french quarter classic with cafe du monde chicory coffee crème anglaise and valrhôna bittersweet chocolate dipping sauce. Their signature dessert is excellent. Freshly fried and lightly sugared with two contrasting dips.

OK:
Half Lobster and Risotto ($26) included a small steamed lobster along with some dense pea risotto. More vegetarian oriented and not very rich. Truffle flavor lacking.

kingfish gumbo ($9) chicken and andouille sausage, mahogany roux, okra,
texas long grain rice was a pretty reasonable version that could use more spice action.

Pans:
None

Service at Kingfish was slightly above average and friendly. They do not have enough waiters, so there were long pauses between visits. This restaurant is a good place for groups and those seeking a change from mundane suburb fare, without driving to the city. Other nearby restaurants worth a visit include Osteria Coppa and Vault 164.

Kingfish on Urbanspoon

Was this review spot on? Do you have anything to add?

Kingfish Overall Rating: (Very Good 2.5)

Come Back?

Food Rating: (Very Good)
Service Rating: (Good)
Atmosphere Rating: (Very Good)
Value Rating: (Good)

Guide: 0 = poor, 1 = Below/Average, 2 = Good, 2.5 = Very Good, 3 = Excellent , 4 = Extraordinary

Alcohol:Full Bar
Attire:Casual
Hours:Mon 1130am-10pm. Tu-Th 1130am-1030pm. Fri 1130am-11pm. Sat 1pm-11pm. Sun 1pm-10pm
Parking:Street
Reservations:Yes
Prices:$9.95 - $30
Posted on January 20th, 2013
If you enjoyed this post, like us on Facebook and Follow us on Twitter.
Be sure to subscribe to our RSS feed.

One Response to “Kingfish Restaurant Review, San Mateo”

  1. Angela Says:

    Hmm, will have to try again. I’ve been twice, a few years back, and had some of the worst food ever. I have friends who live near Kingfish and love to meet there mostly cuz they love a good cocktail and don’t care too much about food. (I care about food, a lot.) Maybe there’s a new chef? Next time they suggest I just might say yes.

Leave a Reply

Please do not put your URL in the comment text and please use your PERSONAL name or initials and not your business name.